Ep. 50: Inside the Delphi, Indiana, Murders Defense: Andrew Baldwin on Strategy, Evidence, and Justice – Part 3 | Hurst Limontes

Andrew Baldwin is Founding Partner and President of The Criminal Defense Team of Baldwin Perry & Kamish, PC, an Indiana law firm dedicated solely to defending individuals facing criminal charges. He is a board‑certified Criminal Trial Specialist, recognized by the National Board of Trial Advocacy for his exceptional trial skill and professionalism. Andrew leads a collaborative team model that ensures multiple attorneys contribute to every case, enhancing strategic thinking and courtroom advocacy. With decades of experience handling high-profile felony cases across Indiana, he is known for his aggressive, team‑driven approach to protecting clients’ rights and achieving strong outcomes.

Here’s a glimpse of what you’ll learn:

[2:07] Andrew Baldwin recalls the alarming decline of Richard Allen on April 3, 2023, and the disputed phone calls
[4:56] Richard Allen’s deep devotion to his wife, Kathy — and how it shaped his decisions in custody
[7:51] False and contradictory confessions from solitary confinement and their psychological context
[12:47] Discovery of prison guards wearing “In Odin We Trust” patches, and the implications for the defense
[16:09] Restrictions on attorney-client access, loss of phone privileges, and questions about DOC credibility
[21:04] Judge’s exclusion of third-party suspect evidence and how it altered the defense strategy
[36:40] Debate over ritualistic crime scene evidence and FBI expert testimony being disregarded
[41:32] The appellate process ahead, challenges of preparing the brief, and timeline for possible retrial

In this episode…

The pursuit of justice in high-profile cases often collides with obstacles such as questionable confessions, restricted evidence, and systemic barriers that prevent juries from hearing the whole story. How can a fair trial be achieved when critical information is suppressed and a defendant’s mental state is compromised?

Andrew Baldwin, a seasoned trial lawyer, provides a candid look at these challenges by recounting Richard Allen’s mental decline in solitary confinement, the emergence of false confessions, and the suspicious behavior of prison staff. Andrew highlights the importance of context in evaluating evidence, exposing how external pressures and restricted access shape narratives. His insights underscore the need for transparency, the admissibility of third-party suspect evidence, and the role of expert testimony in ensuring a fair legal process.

In this episode of Circle City Conversations, Alex Limontes sits down with Andrew Baldwin, Founding Partner of the Criminal Defense Team of Baldwin Perry & Kamish, PC, to discuss strategy, evidence, and justice in the Delphi, Indiana, murders defense. Andrew shares his perspective on flawed confessions, discusses the barriers to presenting third-party defense, and raises questions about ritualistic crime scene evidence. He also examines the appeals process, the effects of solitary confinement, and the resilience of Richard Allen’s family.

Resources mentioned in this episode:

Quotable Moments:

“Rick Allen loves Kathy Allen like no man’s business. That’s real; that’s not some guy.”
“Over the span of the next two or three months, Rick was found in psychosis.”
“They were videotaping our attorney-client meetings through a wall, a glass wall, and reading lips.”
“This is a textbook ritualistic crime scene. Yet we’re not allowed to talk about that evidence.”
“It’s about getting Richard Allen, an innocent man, out of prison for something he didn’t commit.”

Action Steps:

Scrutinize confessions for context: Understanding the circumstances behind statements helps prevent false admissions from shaping wrongful convictions.
Advocate for admissible third-party evidence: Ensuring juries hear all relevant possibilities strengthens the fairness and completeness of trials.
Prioritize mental health in custody: Recognizing the impact of solitary confinement safeguards both due process and humane treatment of defendants.
Challenge questionable courtroom restrictions: Addressing limitations on defense strategies and attorney-client access helps preserve constitutional rights.
Leverage expert testimony effectively: Using credible specialists clarifies complex evidence and protects against misinterpretation in high-stakes cases.

Sponsor for this episode…

This episode is brought to you by Hurst Limontes LLC — a personal injury law firm based in Indiana.

Founded in 1981, Hurst Limontes LLC is one of the few firms whose practice focuses exclusively on victims of negligence and their families.

With more than 116 years of combined experience among our attorneys, you can trust us to handle your cases with valuable and extensive expertise. We have the knowledge to handle any case — from automobile accidents to construction site accidents, firearm discharge accidents, slips and falls, and more.

No matter how complex the case or how significant the injury is, we aim to make the process as stress-free as possible for clients.

Our attorneys have represented thousands of injured clients and obtained hundreds of millions of dollars in settlements and verdicts.

Have you or a family member been a personal injury victim in Indiana? Contact our dedicated team of personal injury lawyers at hurstlimontes.com or email alimontes@hurstlimontes.com.

Ep. 50: Inside the Delphi, Indiana, Murders Defense: Andrew Baldwin on Strategy, Evidence, and Justice – Part 3