Andrew Baldwin is Founding Partner and President of The Criminal Defense Team of Baldwin Perry & Kamish, PC, an Indiana law firm dedicated solely to defending individuals facing criminal charges. He is a board‑certified Criminal Trial Specialist, recognized by the National Board of Trial Advocacy for his exceptional trial skill and professionalism. Andrew leads a collaborative team model that ensures multiple attorneys contribute to every case, enhancing strategic thinking and courtroom advocacy. With decades of experience handling high-profile felony cases across Indiana, he is known for his aggressive, team‑driven approach to protecting clients’ rights and achieving strong outcomes.
Here’s a glimpse of what you’ll learn:
- [4:09] Andrew Baldwin reflects on growing up in Brownsburg, attending Franklin College, and his path to becoming a lawyer
- [6:59] Andrew’s impetus for specializing exclusively in criminal defense and building The Criminal Defense Team
- [10:21] Andrew’s vision for a true team-based law firm where all trial lawyers collaborate
- [17:07] How Andrew humanizes himself during jury selection by exhibiting vulnerability and authenticity
- [21:00] Deciding when a client should testify and why preparation is critical
- [25:30] The Alison Davis murder case, Garmin evidence controversy, and the ultimate not guilty verdict
- [42:05] Andrew’s first impressions of the Delphi, Indiana, murder case, the national media attention, and the case’s overwhelming scale
In this episode…
The Delphi, Indiana, murders captured national attention, leaving behind unanswered questions, disputed evidence, and a community searching for justice. How does a defense attorney approach a case that is both emotionally charged and scrutinized by the public eye?
According to Andrew Baldwin, a nationally recognized criminal defense attorney and board-certified trial specialist, the key lies in relentless preparation and the courage to challenge flawed narratives. He highlights how evidence such as the Garmin watch data could have altered the trajectory of a trial, yet was excluded from consideration. This experience underscores the uphill battle defense lawyers face when judges restrict critical testimony or evidence. Andrew emphasizes that defending high-stakes cases requires not only legal skill but also the ability to humanize defendants, build trust with juries, and remain committed even when the odds appear to be stacked against you.
In this episode of Circle City Conversations, Alex Limontes sits down with Andrew Baldwin, Founding Partner of the Criminal Defense Team of Baldwin Perry & Kamish, PC, to discuss strategy, evidence, and justice in the Delphi, Indiana murders defense. You’ll hear about the challenges of jury selection, how critical evidence was handled, and the philosophy behind team-based trial advocacy. Andrew also shares the realities of criminal defense as both a career and a calling.
Resources mentioned in this episode:
- Alex Limontes: LinkedIn | Bio | Facebook
- Hurst Limontes LLC
- Andrew Baldwin on LinkedIn
- Criminal Defense Team
- Capturing Their Killer: The Girls on the High Bridge
Quotable Moments:
- “I wanted to be a lawyer. I applied to 10 law schools, and one school accepted me.”
- “Whether it’s a good idea or a bad idea, I’m going to stop all the other work.”
- “I love going into work every day, not walking on eggshells, loving that camaraderie and teamwork.”
- “If you’re talking during jury selection, then something is wrong. I need to hear from the jury.”
- “This is not like falling off a bike. If you’re not trying cases, your chops atrophy.”
Action Steps:
- Commit fully to your area of passion: Specializing allows you to refine your skills and build credibility.
- Build a collaborative team structure: Sharing case challenges ensures stronger strategies and prevents burnout by distributing the burden among team members.
- Prepare clients thoroughly for testimony: Witness preparation increases confidence and credibility when facing high-stakes questioning.
- Humanize yourself during jury selection: Vulnerability fosters trust and helps jurors see you as relatable and genuine.
- Treat every case with full effort: Consistent diligence, even on smaller cases, preserves trial skills and protects client outcomes.
Sponsor for this episode…
This episode is brought to you by Hurst Limontes LLC — a personal injury law firm based in Indiana.
Founded in 1981, Hurst Limontes LLC is one of the few firms whose practice focuses exclusively on victims of negligence and their families.
With more than 116 years of combined experience among our attorneys, you can trust us to handle your cases with valuable and extensive expertise. We have the knowledge to handle any case — from automobile accidents to construction site accidents, firearm discharge accidents, slips and falls, and more.
No matter how complex the case or how significant the injury is, we aim to make the process as stress-free as possible for clients.
Our attorneys have represented thousands of injured clients and obtained hundreds of millions of dollars in settlements and verdicts.
Have you or a family member been a personal injury victim in Indiana? Contact our dedicated team of personal injury lawyers at hurstlimontes.com or email alimontes@hurstlimontes.com.
